| Platinum | Pomodori Bistro & Wine Bar |
| Gold | Rosario's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Vinny's Italian Kitchen |
| Bronze | Paisano's Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Bella Union Restaurant and Saloon |
| Top Pick | Cicilys Pastaria & Grill |
| Top Pick | Got Balls Meatball Truck |
| Top Pick | Macaroni's Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |