| Platinum | Crackin' & Stackin' |
| Gold | Over Easy |
| Silver | Punky's Diner & Pies |
| Bronze | Elmer's Restaurants |
| Top Pick | Buttercloud Bakery & Cafe |
| Top Pick | Crater Cafe |
| Top Pick | Parkside Cafe |
| Top Pick | Real Deal Cafe |
| Top Pick | Rooster's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sweet Tea Express |